Dodgers-Giants: Baseball's Greatest Rivalry

Dodgers-Giants

Baseball's Greatest Rivalry

All-Time Teams

The All-Time Teams were picked by me and are unofficial. The stats for each player/manager are 162-game averages based soley on the numbers they accumulated while with the franchise. Averages for pitchers are calculated with the formula used by Baseball-Reference.com. An * means they spent their entire career with the franchise.

All-Time Dodgers
	Starters	R	HR	RBI	SB	AVG	OPS+
C	Roy Campanella 1948-57*	84	32	114	3	.276	124
1B	Gil Hodges 1943, 47-61	88	29	101	5	.274	120
2B	Jackie Robinson 1947-56*	111	16	86	23	.311	132
3B	Ron Cey 1971-82	78	25	92	2	.264	125
SS	Maury Wills 1959-66, 69-72	89	2	38	50	.281	87
LF	Zack Wheat 1909-26	88	9	84	14	.317	130
CF	Duke Snider 1947-62	101	33	107	8	.300	143
RF	Babe Herman 1926-31, 45	99	20	108	13	.339	144

	Bench	R	HR	RBI	SB	AVG	OPS+
C	Mike Piazza 1992-98	99	39	126	2	.331	160
1B	Dolph Camilli 1938-43	104	27	110	6	.270	144
2B	Davey Lopes 1972-81	102	13	52	56	.262	105
SS	Pee Wee Reese 1940-42, 46-58*	100	9	66	17	.269	99
3/O	Pedro Guerrero 1978-88	88	27	91	13	.309	149
OF	Carl Furillo 1946-60*	80	17	95	4	.299	113
OF	Willie Davis 1960-73	83	13	70	28	.279	107

	Lineup
SS LF 2B CF C RF 1B 3B	Maury Wills + Zack Wheat ^ Jackie Robinson Duke Snider ^ Roy Campanella Babe Herman ^ Gil Hodges Ron Cey
^ Left-handed hitter, + Switch-hitter

All-Time Dodgers
	Starting Pitchers	HP	W	L	SO	ERA
SP	Sandy Koufax 1955-66*	L	16	8	229	2.76
SP	Don Sutton 1966-80, 88	R	15	11	169	3.09
SP	Don Drysdale 1956-69*	R	14	11	172	2.95
SP	Dazzy Vance 1922-32, 35	R	18	13	185	3.17

	Bullpen	HP	W	L	SV	SO	ERA
CL	Eric Gagne 1999-2006	R	5	4	32	124	3.27
RP	Jim Brewer 1964-75	R	8	7	17	93	2.62
RP	Ron Perranoski 1961-67, 72	L	8	6	15	68	2.56
RP	Orel Hershiser 1983-94, 2000	R	14	11	1	150	3.12
RP	Jeff Pfeffer 1913-21	R	18	12	1	105	2.31
RP	Burleigh Grimes 1918-26	R	18	14	1	107	3.47

All-Time Dodgers
Manager	W	L	WP	PNT	WS
Walter Alston 1954-76*	90	71	.558	7	4

All-Tenured Dodgers
	Most Games by Position
C	Mike Scioscia	1395	1980-92*
1B	Gil Hodges	1851	1943, 47-61
2B	Davey Lopes	1150	1972-81
3B	Ron Cey	1468	1971-82
SS	Pee Wee Reese	2014	1940-42, 46-58*
OF	Zack Wheat	2275	1909-26
OF	Willie Davis	1906	1960-73
OF	Duke Snider	1769	1947-62
SP	Don Sutton	533	1966-80, 88
RP	Jim Brewer ^	456	1964-75
^ Brewer and Ron Perranoski each had 456 relief appearances. Brewer gets the nod with 18 starts to Perranoski's 1.

All-Time Giants
	Starters	R	HR	RBI	SB	AVG	OPS+
C	Buck Ewing 1883-92	142	10	101	63	.306	147
1B	Bill Terry 1923-36*	105	15	101	5	.341	136
2B	Jeff Kent 1997-2002	103	32	124	10	.297	138
3B	Fred Linstrom 1924-32	105	14	90	12	.318	112
SS	George Davis 1893-1901, 03	124	8	121	52	.332	132
LF	Barry Bonds 1993-2007	127	48	118	22	.312	200
CF	Willie Mays 1951-72	114	37	105	19	.304	158
RF	Mel Ott 1926-47*	110	30	110	5	.304	155

	Bench	R	HR	RBI	SB	AVG	OPS+
C	Roger Bresnahan 1902-08	94	3	63	25	.293	140
1B	Willie McCovey 1959-73, 77-80	80	34	100	2	.274	150
1B	Orlando Cepeda 1958-66	95	33	112	13	.308	140
1B	Roger Connor 1883-89, 91, 93-94	137	11	114	32	.319	162
2B	Larry Doyle 1907-16, 18-20	90	7	72	29	.292	127
SS	Travis Jackson 1922-36*	81	13	91	7	.291	102
OF	Bobby Bonds 1968-74	122	30	88	42	.273	132

	Lineup
SS C 1B LF CF RF 2B 3B	George Davis + Buck Ewing Bill Terry ^ Barry Bonds ^ Willie Mays Mel Ott ^ Jeff Kent Fred Lindstrom
^ Left-handed hitter, + Switch-hitter

All-Time Giants
	Starting Pitchers	HP	W	L	SO	ERA
SP	Christy Mathewson 1900-16	R	21	11	144	2.12
SP	Carl Hubbell 1928-43*	L	18	11	118	2.98
SP	Juan Marichal 1960-73	R	18	11	172	2.84
SP	Tim Keefe 1885-91	R	22	10	164	2.53

	Bullpen	HP	W	L	SV	SO	ERA
CL	Robb Nen 1998-2002	R	4	5	38	84	2.43
RP	Greg Minton 1975-87	R	5	6	15	43	3.23
RP	Gary Lavelle 1974-84	L	8	7	13	73	2.82
RP	Gaylord Perry 1962-71	R	14	11	1	168	2.96
RP	Joe McGinnity 1902-08	R	19	11	3	100	2.38
RP	Rube Marquard 1908-15	L	16	12	2	143	2.85

All-Time Giants
Manager	W	L	WP	PNT	WS
John McGraw 1902-32	95	66	.591	10	3

All-Tenured Giants
	Most Games by Position
C	Wes Westrum	902	1947-57*
1B	Willie McCovey	1775	1959-73, 77-80
2B	Larry Doyle	1591	1907-16, 18-20
3B	Jim Davenport	1130	1958-70*
SS	Travis Jackson	1326	1922-36*
OF	Willie Mays	2748	1951-72
OF	Mel Ott	2313	1926-47*
OF	Barry Bonds	1891	1993-2007
SP	Christy Mathewson	550	1900-16
RP	Gary Lavelle	644	1974-84

Traitors
209 players have played for both franchises	15 players have played for both franchises exclusively